Indra Robinson

WritingEssay 04

That’s Just Who I Am

On the things we call personality, the fears we stop recognizing, and the possibilities we might be leaving unexplored.

There’s a sentence people use that I’ve been thinking about lately.

“That’s just who I am.”

It’s usually said with such certainty that there’s not much point continuing the conversation.

I’m not adventurous. I don’t like trying new things. I could never do something like that. I’m too old to start now.

Fair enough. We all have our preferences.

But I’ve started wondering how much of what we consider our personality is actually who we are, and how much is the result of decisions we’ve made over the years without ever questioning them again.

Because here’s something I’ve noticed. People can become incredibly good at explaining why they can’t do something they haven’t even tried.

And sometimes, I think the explanation has very little to do with the thing itself.

The comfort of being realistic

We’re raised to be sensible.

Go to school, get your education, find a good job, make responsible decisions. Don’t take unnecessary chances. Think about what could go wrong.

None of that is particularly bad advice.

The problem begins when we become so good at identifying what could go wrong that we stop considering what could go right.

Someone presents an idea, and before they’ve finished explaining it, we’ve already dismissed it.

Too risky. Too expensive. Too complicated.

Sometimes the concerns are completely legitimate. People have obligations, financial limitations, and circumstances that make certain decisions difficult.

But sometimes we’re just afraid.

And there’s nothing particularly shameful about that.

I’ve been afraid of plenty of things. I understand how convincing fear can be, especially when it arrives dressed as perfectly reasonable advice.

What interests me is how rarely we recognize it for what it is.

We don’t necessarily say, “I’m afraid to try that.”

We say, “That’s not really my thing.”

And eventually we believe it.

What began as self-protection can eventually become self-definition.

When fear becomes familiar

Imagine avoiding something because it makes you uncomfortable.

The first time, you know you’re avoiding it. You might even feel disappointed with yourself afterward.

The second time is easier. You already have a perfectly reasonable explanation.

Keep doing it long enough, and something interesting happens.

You stop experiencing the decision as avoidance. It becomes a preference.

You don’t travel because you’re not a traveler. You don’t meet new people because you’re not a social person. You don’t experiment because you’re someone who prefers certainty.

And maybe all of that is true.

But have you ever stopped to wonder whether it’s something you genuinely dislike, or simply something you’ve become accustomed to avoiding?

I think there’s a difference worth paying attention to.

Because when we acknowledge being afraid, we can actually do something with that information.

We can ask questions. We can learn more. We can talk to somebody who’s done the thing we’re afraid of. We can decide that the risk isn’t worth taking, or discover that it isn’t nearly as frightening as we imagined.

At least we’re making a conscious decision.

But when fear becomes part of how we describe ourselves, we rarely revisit it.

It’s settled. That’s who we are.

And I wonder how many people have spent years living inside a definition of themselves that they arrived at under completely different circumstances.

The uncomfortable mirror

There’s another side to this that I find fascinating.

Have you noticed how differently people react when someone they know starts doing something unexpected?

One person becomes excited.

“Wait, you did that? How? Tell me everything.”

Another immediately starts explaining why the person was able to do it.

They probably had money. They knew the right people. They had an advantage.

Sometimes those assumptions are accurate. Money, connections, timing, and opportunities make a difference. Not everyone starts from the same place.

But it’s interesting how quickly people can invent an explanation without knowing the circumstances.

I sometimes wonder whether someone else’s willingness to take a chance can make us uncomfortable with our own choices.

It’s like having a mirror placed in front of you when you weren’t planning to look at yourself.

You see somebody doing something you’ve always dismissed as impossible. Suddenly the explanation you’ve been giving yourself doesn’t feel quite so convincing.

You have a choice. You can become curious, or you can find a reason why their experience has nothing to do with you.

And the second option is considerably more comfortable.

Because curiosity could lead somewhere.

It could make you question something you’ve believed for years.

And then what?

The things we never admitted wanting

I think this is where fear gets complicated.

Admitting you’re afraid is one thing. Admitting you’ve been afraid for years, and that the fear might have influenced some fairly significant decisions, is something else entirely.

You might have to acknowledge that you wanted something you never pursued.

That you dismissed an opportunity because you couldn’t imagine yourself succeeding.

That something you described as impossible might actually have been possible, even if there was no guarantee it would work out.

There’s no way to know what would have happened. And I don’t think dwelling on every road we didn’t take is particularly useful.

But I can understand why somebody might resist examining those decisions.

It’s painful to consider that you may have spent years protecting yourself from an outcome that never even had a chance to happen.

Much easier to say you were never interested.

And after enough time, who knows? You might not even remember that you once were.

At some point, being realistic can become a very convincing way of never finding out what else was possible.

Whatever happened to our joie de vivre?

There’s a French expression I’ve always loved: joie de vivre.

The joy of living.

I love everything about that expression. It describes something I think we sometimes forget to make room for as adults.

That feeling of excitement about life. The pleasure of discovering something new. Looking forward to tomorrow because there’s something you’re curious about, something you want to experience, or something you haven’t figured out yet.

As children, we’re encouraged to explore. We ask questions, come up with ridiculous ideas, and change our minds about what we want to become.

Then we grow up.

And suddenly we’re expected to have figured ourselves out.

We settle into our responsibilities, establish routines, and begin treating our personalities as though they’re finished products.

I find that rather strange.

Why should we assume that the person we became at thirty is the person we have to remain at fifty?

We learn new things about the world all the time. Surely we can still learn something new about ourselves.

I don’t think a good life has to be particularly adventurous. Someone can find tremendous joy in a familiar routine, a small circle of friends, and a perfectly ordinary Tuesday.

That’s wonderful, if it’s what they genuinely enjoy.

What I question is the assumption that wanting to explore something different automatically means being irresponsible, ungrateful, or dissatisfied.

You can appreciate your life and still be curious about what else it might hold.

And you don’t need to wait for some extraordinary event to give yourself permission to enjoy it.

Leaving room to change

I don’t believe everyone needs to take bigger risks. Some risks simply aren’t worth it, and some people are very happy with the lives they’ve chosen.

I also don’t believe we can look at another person and decide that their life is too small. We don’t get to make that judgment for them.

But I do think we should occasionally question the things we’ve spent years telling ourselves.

Especially the ones that begin with “I could never.”

Because sometimes that’s a genuine assessment of our circumstances.

And sometimes it’s just an old fear we’ve become very comfortable living with.

I’ve said “That’s just who I am” myself. I’m sure I’ll say it again.

But I’d like to be a little more curious when I catch myself doing it.

Not because every no should become a yes.

I just don’t want to spend the rest of my life confusing something I’m afraid to do with something I’m incapable of doing.

There’s still a lot I haven’t tried.

And I’d like to keep it that way for a while, with the possibility of changing my mind whenever something interesting comes along.