Indra Robinson

WritingEssay 05

When a Yes Costs More Than a No

On the cost of pushing for a yes, and why an honest no can be better for both sides of a sale.

Recently, I had a conversation that brought me back to something I’ve been thinking about for a while. Why does so much of the language around sales sound like we’re preparing for battle?

We’re taught to hunt, overcome resistance, attack objections and close. Somewhere in all of that, the person on the other end of the conversation can start to feel like an obstacle standing between us and a commission.

I’ve always had a problem with that approach. Partly because I don’t enjoy being sold to that way myself. But also because I wonder how often a salesperson celebrates a yes that the customer is already beginning to regret.

Think about it.

Someone expresses interest in a product or service. A conversation begins, and somewhere along the way, they hesitate. Maybe it’s the price. Maybe the timing isn’t right. Maybe they’re still trying to figure out whether they even need what you’re offering.

But instead of treating that hesitation as information, we’re often taught to treat it as resistance.

And resistance, apparently, is something to overcome.

So we keep talking. We reframe the objection. We introduce urgency. We find another angle until the person finally says yes.

Congratulations. You’ve made the sale.

But what exactly have you accomplished?

Because now that person has to live with a decision they may not have been comfortable making. And if they wake up tomorrow wondering why they agreed, that becomes your problem too.

The second-guessing begins. The requests for reassurance. Perhaps the cancellation or refund request. Sometimes the frustration gets directed at the very person who convinced them to buy.

All that effort spent securing a yes, only to spend even more effort managing the consequences.

I find that fascinating, because we measure so much of sales success by whether somebody buys. We pay less attention to whether they actually wanted to.

There’s also something about the language itself that bothers me. This idea that being good at sales requires a certain toughness. That you have to be relentless, assertive, almost combative. I’ve heard it presented as the kind of confidence you need to succeed, and I wonder how many people have learned to imitate a personality that doesn’t even feel natural to them.

I don’t believe you have to become that person to be effective at selling.

I believe in persuasion. A good conversation can help someone recognize a problem, understand a solution, or see possibilities they hadn’t considered. Sometimes people genuinely need help working through uncertainty.

But there’s a difference between helping someone arrive at a decision and wearing them down until they make one.

And I think we should be more willing to hear no.

A genuine no tells you something. Maybe the person isn’t ready. Maybe they can’t afford it. Maybe what you’re offering simply isn’t right for them.

That’s useful information.

Why would I want to spend another hour trying to change someone’s mind when I could be talking to somebody who genuinely needs what I offer?

And why should that person have to keep defending a decision they’ve already made?

Of course, a no can be disappointing. Especially when you’re building a business, trying to meet your numbers, or counting on the next customer. I understand the pressure. But turning every hesitation into an objection to defeat can create problems long after the sales conversation ends.

I’ve been thinking about what a successful sales conversation should actually look like.

Maybe sometimes it’s a purchase. Sometimes it’s a person leaving with a better understanding of what they need. And sometimes it’s two people recognizing that they aren’t a good fit and parting on perfectly good terms.

I can live with that.

I’d rather hear an honest no today than spend the next three months trying to make someone feel good about a yes they never really meant.